From Defense to Transference: How Character Defenses Re-Create Relationships From the Past.
David M. Rudesill, LCSW
Certified IEDTA Teacher
One of the most useful shifts in learning to work with resistance is moving from asking:
“What defense is the patient using?”
to asking:
“What kind of relationship does this defense create?”
A character defense is often best understood as a relationship-making mechanism.
It does more than protect a patient from a feeling. It organizes how the patient relates to others and the therapist, what role others and therapist is invited to occupy, and what kind of interpersonal experience gets recreated again and again.
This is where defense work begins to become transference resistance work.
Defense Identification Is Only the Beginning
Imagine a patient who becomes detached whenever strong feelings begin to emerge.
At first, we might simply identify the defense:
The patient is detaching, "Notice how you detach?"
Then we might ask what the defense accomplishes:
Detachment reduces anxiety and creates distance from painful feelings.
Both observations are useful. But neither yet tells us what happens between patient and therapist.
To understand the transference resistance, we need another question:
What happens to relationships when the patient detaches?
Perhaps the patient remains physically present but becomes emotionally unavailable. The therapist begins asking more questions, trying harder to understand, searching for the feeling, generating direction, or working to bring the patient back into contact.
Now we have something much more clinically useful.
The patient's defense is no longer merely an internal event.
It has begun to organize a relationship.
A Six-Step Way to Identify Transference Resistance
A useful sequence is:
Defense → Function → Therapist Pull → Dyadic Roles → Relational Consequence → Patient Choice
1. Identify the observable defense
Start with what can actually be seen or heard.
The patient may:
detach;
intellectualize;
become vague;
say “I don't know” repeatedly;
minimize;
shift into self-criticism;
become passive;
wait for the therapist to generate the next step.
The goal is not to interpret motive prematurely. Start with observable behavior.
2. Clarify what the defense accomplishes
Defenses exist for a reason.
For example, emotional detachment can be extremely effective at reducing anxiety. If I disconnect from what I feel, the anxiety associated with those feelings may decrease.
The problem is that feelings, desires, impulses, and a sense of personal direction may also become less accessible.
The defense solves one problem while creating another.
That is why simply telling a patient to “stop detaching” is rarely useful.
We want the patient to understand both the protection and the price.
3. Notice what the patient pulls the therapist to do
This is one of the most important sources of clinical information.
A patient may say:
“I don't know what to do with this.”
On the surface, this sounds like a request for help.
But before answering, it can be useful for the therapist to notice:
What am I suddenly pulled to do?
Do I want to:
explain?
reassure?
solve the problem?
give advice?
generate motivation?
find the patient's feelings for them?
move the session forward because the patient isn't?
These reactions are not proof of what is happening. But they are valuable countertransference data.
The therapist's urge to work harder may be telling us something about the relational position the patient is taking.
4. Identify the roles being created
Suppose a highly capable patient repeatedly presents as though they do not know what to do and then waits.
If the therapist responds by taking charge, the relationship may gradually organize itself around:
Therapist = capable, knowing, active, directing
Patient = uncertain, less capable, waiting, following
Now we are no longer describing a defense alone.
We are describing a dyadic structure.
This is what makes transference resistance so important.
The patient may unintentionally recreate the same relational position in therapy that causes suffering elsewhere.
5. Clarify the relational consequence
Once the roles become visible, the next question is:
What does this relationship cost the patient?
Consider someone whose central life struggle involves trusting their own creative direction.
They may want to write, create, lead, take risks, or pursue a career that feels personally meaningful.
But if they repeatedly enter relationships in which someone else becomes the capable person who provides direction, their own agency remains underdeveloped.
The defense then produces the very outcome the patient fears:
“Maybe I'm not capable.”
This is one reason character defenses can become so self-confirming.
The patient behaves in a way that invites others to occupy a certain role. The resulting relationship then appears to confirm the patient's beliefs about themselves.
“Here, But Not Here”
Detachment offers another clear example.
A patient may be sitting across from the therapist, speaking intelligently and even describing their psychology with remarkable precision.
Yet something relational is missing.
The patient is physically here, but not here in an essential way.
They may understand their feelings intellectually while remaining emotionally absent from the person sitting with them.
The clinical question becomes:
What kind of relationship is created when the patient disappears emotionally?
Perhaps the therapist becomes the person trying to reach them.
Perhaps other people in the patient's life have historically occupied the same role.
Now a familiar interpersonal system is being recreated:
Patient withdraws → other reaches → patient remains distant → other works harder.
The defense is making a relationship.
Why Insight Alone May Not Change the Pattern
Some patients can describe their defenses beautifully.
They understand their childhood histories.
They know their attachment patterns.
They can explain exactly why they become anxious, detached, self-critical, or passive.
And yet the pattern continues.
This can be confusing for both patient and therapist.
But insight into a defense is not necessarily the same thing as experiencing the defense as it happens in a relationship.
A patient may know:
“I detach when I have strong feelings.”
That is different from recognizing:
“I'm detaching from you right now. As I do that, you're beginning to work harder to reach me. I become less involved, and you become more active. This is the relationship we're creating together.”
The second observation brings the resistance into the room.
Now the patient has an opportunity to see not only what they do, but what it makes happen.
The Therapist's Overfunctioning Can Become Part of the Resistance
Passive or detached resistance can be particularly difficult to recognize because the therapist often experiences the problem first as:
“I'm not doing enough.”
The therapist may ask more questions.
Offer longer summaries.
Try another interpretation.
Increase pressure.
Search for the patient's motivation.
Work harder to make the session productive.
But this can inadvertently complete the interpersonal pattern.
The patient becomes increasingly passive while the therapist becomes increasingly active.
A useful internal question is:
“Why am I working this hard right now?”
Sometimes the answer is simply that the clinical material is complex.
But sometimes the therapist's overfunctioning is evidence that the patient has already taken a position of relative underfunctioning.
That moment is worth examining.
Don't "Attack the Defense."
Seeing the transference resistance clearly does not mean confronting the patient aggressively.
The defense developed for a good reason. It saved their life or helped them remain attached to a loved one.
Detachment may have reduced overwhelming anxiety.
Compliance may once have protected an important relationship.
Passivity may have been safer than asserting a separate will.
Intellectualization may have allowed a patient to maintain control when emotional experience felt dangerous.
The therapeutic task is not to shame the patient for having a defense.
It is to help the patient see:
This is what the defense protects you from.
This is the relationship dynamics it creates and recreates.
This is what that relationship costs you.
And now you get to decide whether you still want to use it.
Returning the Conflict to the Patient
This last step is crucial.
If the therapist becomes the person arguing for health, agency, courage, connection, or change, the conflict has moved out of the patient and into the relationship.
The therapist becomes the healthy side.
The patient becomes the resistance.
Now the therapy can turn into a tug-of-war.
Instead, effective transference resistance work aims to return the conflict to where it belongs:
inside the patient.
The patient begins to experience:
“Part of me wants this life.”
and simultaneously:
“Part of me is doing something that prevents me from moving toward it.”
That is a productive internal conflict.
The therapist does not need to supply the patient's will.
The therapist can help the patient see what interferes with it.
From Defense Work to Transference Work
A useful progression is:
1. What is the patient doing?Identify the defense.
2. What does it protect the patient from?Clarify its function.
3. What does it pull me to do?Use countertransference as data.
4. What roles are we beginning to occupy?Identify the transference structure.
5. What happens to the patient in this relationship?Clarify the interpersonal cost.
6. Is this what the patient wants?Return agency and choice.
This is the movement from simply identifying defenses to understanding transference resistance.
And it leads to a broader clinical principle:
Character defenses do not merely regulate feelings. They organize relationships.
When we can see the relationship a defense creates, we gain access to something much larger than the defense itself.
We begin to see how a patient's internal psychological system repeatedly becomes an interpersonal one—how familiar roles are recreated, how others are recruited into those roles, and how the resulting relationships perpetuate the very suffering the patient came to therapy hoping to change.
That is where transference resistance work becomes both powerful and deeply practical.



Comments